Skip to content
Man MadeThings

The Best First Watch for a New Collector: Casio, Timex and Seiko

Starting a watch collection? Here are three first watches at three budgets: a G-Shock, a Timex Weekender and an automatic Seiko 5 Sports, with specs checked at the source.

Aditya GudlavalletiAditya GudlavalletiWatches & Coffee WriterPublished · 5 min read

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. Learn more

A digital, a classic analog and an automatic watch side by side
Image: Man Made Things

Quick answer

The best first watch depends on what you want to learn. The Casio G-Shock DW5600UE-1 ($99.95) is nearly indestructible and does everything. The Timex Weekender ($77) teaches you what you like about an analog dial for very little money. The Seiko 5 Sports SRPD59 ($350) is the classic first automatic, with a hacking, hand-windable movement and 100m water resistance.

Everyone who's into watches remembers their first "real" one. Not the plastic one from a birthday party, but the first watch they chose on purpose. That first pick shapes everything after it.

Here's the honest advice I wish more people heard: your first watch shouldn't be expensive. It should teach you what you like. Do you prefer digital or analog? Big or small? Do you want the ticking ritual of a mechanical watch, or something you never think about?

So instead of three versions of the same watch, I picked three different kinds at three budgets. Every spec and price comes from the brand's own US site. These are research-based picks with no star scores. Let's get into it.

Our picks at a glance

  1. Casio G-Shock DW5600UE-1 digital watch

    Best tough digital

    Casio G-Shock DW5600UE-1

    List price $99.95

    Check price ↗
  2. Timex Weekender 38mm with black dial on a black fabric strap

    Best classic analog

    Timex Weekender 38mm Fabric Strap Watch

    List price $77

    Check price ↗
  3. Seiko 5 Sports SRPD59 with orange dial on a steel bracelet

    Best first automatic

    Seiko 5 Sports SRPD59

    List price $350

    Check price ↗

1. Best tough digital

Casio G-Shock DW5600UE-1

Casio G-Shock DW5600UE-1 digital watch
Image: Casio

The square G-Shock 5600 is one of the most recognizable watches ever made, and it's still one of the smartest first buys. It's light at 52 grams, rated to 200m of water resistance, and Casio builds it to survive drops and knocks that would destroy most watches.

It also does a lot. There's a stopwatch, a countdown timer, alarms, a bright LED backlight and a calendar that's set until 2099. The battery lasts about five years, and Casio rates accuracy at plus or minus 15 seconds a month.

Is it a "nice" watch? Not in the jewelry sense. But it's the watch you can wear to the beach, the gym and a hike without ever worrying about it. Lots of serious collectors still own one for exactly that reason.

Pros

  1. 01Built to take knocks and drops
  2. 02200 m water resistance
  3. 03About 5-year battery
  4. 04Stopwatch, timer, alarms and backlight

Cons

  1. 01Resin case looks casual
  2. 02Digital display isn't for dressy outfits
Case48.9 × 42.8 × 13.4 mm, resin, 52 g
ToughnessShock resistant
Water resistance200 m
BatteryAbout 5 years (CR2016)
LightLED backlight with afterglow
FunctionsStopwatch, 24-hr countdown, alarms, auto-calendar to 2099
Accuracy±15 seconds per month

2. Best classic analog

Timex Weekender 38mm Fabric Strap Watch

Timex Weekender 38mm with black dial on a black fabric strap
Image: Timex

The Weekender is the watch I'd hand anyone who's never worn one. It's simple, readable and cheap enough that you won't stress about scratching it.

At 38mm, it's a classic size that suits most wrists, and the full set of Arabic numerals is easy to read at a glance. Press the crown and the whole dial lights up with INDIGLO, the backlight Timex developed in the early '90s. The slip-through fabric strap is comfortable and easy to swap, and changing straps is the cheapest way to make one watch feel like several.

The big limitation is water. Timex rates it at 30m, which it says is fine for splashes and hand washing but not for showering or swimming. Take it off before you get in the pool.

Pros

  1. 01Very affordable at $77
  2. 02Classic 38 mm size
  3. 03INDIGLO lights the whole dial
  4. 04Easy to swap straps

Cons

  1. 01Only 30 m water resistance, no swimming
  2. 02Brass case and mineral crystal are basic
Case38 mm, brass, silver-tone
MovementQuartz (CR2016 battery)
DialBlack, full Arabic numerals
LightINDIGLO light-up dial
CrystalMineral
Water resistance30 m (splashes and hand washing only)
StrapFabric slip-through, 20 mm

3. Best first automatic

Seiko 5 Sports SRPD59

Seiko 5 Sports SRPD59 with orange dial on a steel bracelet
Image: Seiko

If the idea of a tiny machine on your wrist excites you, this is where to start. The Seiko 5 Sports line is the classic first automatic, and the SRPD59 adds a bright orange sunray dial to the SKX-inspired design many collectors love.

Inside is Seiko's 4R36, a proven movement that winds itself as you move, can be wound by hand and hacks so you can set it to the second. Turn it over and a see-through caseback lets you watch it work. You also get 100m of water resistance, a day-date and LumiBrite lume.

At 42.5mm, it's on the larger side, though the 46mm lug-to-lug keeps it wearable. Note that the black and blue versions of this model were sold out on Seiko USA when I checked, which is why the orange one is here.

Pros

  1. 01Proven automatic, hand-winding and hacking
  2. 02100 m water resistance
  3. 03See-through caseback
  4. 04Bright, fun orange dial

Cons

  1. 0142.5 mm may feel big on small wrists
  2. 02Hardlex crystal, not sapphire
  3. 03Other colors were sold out on Seiko USA
Case42.5 mm, 13.4 mm thick, 46 mm lug to lug, steel
MovementSeiko 4R36 automatic, hand-winding, hacking
Power reserveAbout 41 hours
CrystalHardlex
Water resistance100 m
ExtrasDay-date, one-way bezel, display caseback, LumiBrite

Quartz or automatic for your first watch?

Comparison of quartz and automatic watch movements for first-time buyers
Image: Man Made Things

This is the first big fork in the road.

Quartz watches run on a battery. Timex calls quartz "highly accurate," and it is: a few seconds off a month is typical. You set it and forget it for years. The G-Shock and the Weekender are both quartz.

Automatic watches are mechanical. Citizen explains that they never need a battery because a weight inside winds them as your arm moves. They're less accurate and stop if you leave them in a drawer for a couple of days, but many people love them for the craft.

My advice: if you're not sure, start with quartz. If you already know you're curious about how watches work, go straight to an automatic like the Seiko.

Whichever you choose, wear it every day for a few weeks before you judge it. A watch that feels too big in the box often feels right by day three, and a watch you loved in photos might bug you on the wrist. That daily wear is how you figure out what your second watch should be.

What water resistance ratings really mean

Chart of what 30m, 50m, 100m and 200m water resistance ratings mean in daily life
Image: Man Made Things

The numbers on a watch don't mean you can dive that deep. Timex's own guide translates them like this:

  • 30m: light rain, sweat and splashes.
  • 50m: short swims.
  • 100m: swimming, snorkeling and surfing.
  • 200m: recreational scuba diving.

Timex also advises not pressing buttons while the watch is wet. For a first watch, aim for at least 100m if you swim, or don't worry about it if you'll mostly wear it to work and dinner.

What to buy next

Once you've worn your first watch for a few months, you'll know what you like, and the next step gets easier. Loved the toughness? Look at our best dive watches under $1,000. Want something simple and smart? Try our best field watches. Curious about all the styles? Read dress, dive, field or GMT.

The best collection isn't the most expensive one. It's the one where every watch earns its place on your wrist.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good first watch?

+

It depends on your style. The Casio G-Shock DW5600UE-1 is a tough digital, the Timex Weekender is a simple $77 analog, and the Seiko 5 Sports SRPD59 is a classic first automatic at $350.

Should my first watch be quartz or automatic?

+

Quartz is more accurate and lower maintenance. Automatic is mechanical and needs regular wear or winding. If you're unsure, start with quartz.

How much should I spend on my first watch?

+

You don't need to spend much. Great first watches start under $100, and a quality automatic like the Seiko 5 Sports costs about $350.

Can I swim with a Timex Weekender?

+

No. Timex rates it at 30m, which covers splashes and hand washing but not swimming or showering.

Sources

Aditya Gudlavalleti
Aditya Gudlavalleti

Watches & Coffee Writer

Aditya is a passionate coffee lover who loves watches. He covers watches and coffee for Man Made Things.

More from Aditya →

Keep reading