Skip to content
Man MadeThings

Moccamaster vs Breville Luxe Brewer vs Bonavita: Which Drip Coffee Maker Should You Buy?

Three SCA-certified drip coffee makers compared on official specs: the Moccamaster KBGV, Breville Luxe Brewer Thermal and Bonavita Connoisseur. Capacity, carafes, programming, brew temperature, warranty and price, plus our value math.

Aditya GudlavalletiAditya GudlavalletiWatches & Coffee WriterPublished · 5 min read

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. Learn more

Moccamaster KBGV drip coffee maker with glass carafe
Image: Moccamaster

Quick answer

All three are SCA-certified drip coffee makers. Choose the Moccamaster KBGV ($369) for simplicity, a 5-year warranty and a handmade Dutch build. Choose the Breville Luxe Brewer Thermal ($349.95) if you want control: a 24-hour delayed start, custom temperature, bloom and flow, a thermal carafe and a cold brew mode. Choose the Bonavita Connoisseur ($189.99) for the best value, with a thermal carafe and 195–205°F brewing for about half the price.

If you want great coffee from a machine without fiddling with a pour-over kettle, a quality drip brewer is the answer. And the easiest way to find a good one is to look for SCA certification: the Specialty Coffee Association only certifies home brewers that pass third-party testing for brewing quality and consistency.

All three machines here are SCA certified, but they're built for different people. As a coffee lover, I compared them on the specs each maker publishes, from our best drip coffee makers guide. Prices are each brand's official US list price. These are research-based comparisons, not taste tests, and there are no scores.

At a glance

Drip coffee makers compared: Moccamaster KBGV $369, 10 cups, glass carafe, 5-year warranty; Breville Luxe Brewer $349.95, 12 cups, thermal carafe, 2-year warranty; Bonavita Connoisseur $189.99, 8 cups, thermal carafe, 1-year warranty
Image: Man Made Things
Moccamaster KBGV Breville Luxe Brewer Thermal Bonavita Connoisseur
Price $369 $349.95 $189.99
Capacity 1.25 L (10 cups) 60 oz (12 cups) 8 cups
Carafe Glass, on a hotplate Dual-wall thermal Double-wall stainless thermal
Programmable No (auto-off after 100 min) Yes, delayed start up to 24 h No timer
Custom settings Full or half carafe Bloom, temperature, flow rate Optional bloom mode
Certification SCA and ECBC SCA SCA
Warranty 5 years 2 years 1 year
Made in Handmade in the Netherlands Not stated Not stated

Moccamaster KBGV: simple, with a 5-year warranty

Moccamaster KBGV drip coffee maker
Image: Moccamaster

The Moccamaster is the simplest of the three: fill it, switch it on, and it brews. There's no timer or app, just a switch for a full or half carafe. Moccamaster says each one is handmade in the Netherlands, it's certified by both the SCA and the European Coffee Brewing Centre (ECBC), and it carries the longest warranty here, 5 years.

The trade-off is the glass carafe, which sits on a hotplate rather than being insulated, and the machine turns off after 100 minutes. If you like to sip slowly through the morning, a thermal carafe may suit you better.

Breville Luxe Brewer Thermal: the most control

Breville Luxe Brewer Thermal coffee maker
Image: Breville

If you like to tinker, or want coffee ready when you wake up, the Breville is the clear choice. You can set a delayed start up to 24 hours, and customize the bloom, brew temperature and flow rate. It also has a cold brew mode and can brew a single cup or a full carafe, with flat and cone baskets.

Its dual-wall thermal carafe keeps coffee above 150°F for up to 4 hours, Breville says, with no hotplate. The downsides are a 2-year warranty and more settings to learn. It brews up to 60 ounces, the most here.

Bonavita Connoisseur: the best value

Bonavita Connoisseur 8-cup coffee brewer with thermal carafe
Image: Bonavita

At $189.99, the Bonavita is about half the price of the others, and it's still SCA certified. Bonavita says it holds the water at 195–205°F through the whole brew and makes a full carafe in about 6 minutes, with an optional pre-infusion (bloom) mode. It also has a stainless thermal carafe.

What you give up: no timer or delayed start, a smaller 8-cup capacity and a 1-year warranty. For most people who just want a great pot of coffee, it's all the machine they need.

Value math: what each year of warranty costs

Drip coffee maker value math: price per year of warranty, Moccamaster about $74, Breville about $175, Bonavita about $190; price per cup of capacity, Bonavita about $24, Breville about $29, Moccamaster about $37
Image: Man Made Things

Using our usual approach (see our watch value math for the idea), here's what you pay per year of warranty and per cup of capacity:

Brewer Price Warranty Price per warranty year Price per cup of capacity
Moccamaster KBGV $369 5 years ~$74 ~$37 (10 cups)
Breville Luxe Brewer $349.95 2 years ~$175 ~$29 (12 cups)
Bonavita Connoisseur $189.99 1 year ~$190 ~$24 (8 cups)

What it shows: the Moccamaster's long warranty makes it the cheapest per year of coverage, despite the highest price. The Bonavita is the cheapest per cup of capacity. These are rough measures, not a prediction of how long each machine will last.

Which should you buy?

Which drip brewer: Moccamaster for simplicity and a 5-year warranty; Breville for programming and control; Bonavita for value
Image: Man Made Things
  • Buy the Moccamaster KBGV if you want the simplest machine with the longest warranty, and you drink your coffee soon after brewing.
  • Buy the Breville Luxe Brewer if you want a timer, custom settings, cold brew and a thermal carafe.
  • Buy the Bonavita Connoisseur if you want SCA-certified coffee for the least money.

Whichever you choose, the biggest improvement to drip coffee is fresh beans ground right before brewing. See our best burr coffee grinders and our De/code: a coffee bag to pick better beans.

Glass carafe or thermal?

Glass vs thermal carafe: the Moccamaster's glass carafe sits on a hotplate and switches off after 100 minutes; the Breville's dual-wall thermal carafe keeps coffee above 150°F for up to 4 hours; the Bonavita has a stainless thermal carafe
Image: Man Made Things

The carafe is one of the biggest practical differences between these brewers:

  • Glass on a hotplate (Moccamaster KBGV): you can see how much coffee is left, and the hotplate keeps it warm, but the machine switches off after 100 minutes.
  • Thermal (Breville and Bonavita): an insulated carafe keeps coffee hot with no hotplate. Breville says its dual-wall carafe keeps coffee above 150°F for up to 4 hours, and you can carry it to the table.

Pick by how you drink: if you pour a couple of cups right after brewing, glass is fine. If coffee sits for hours, or you brew for a group, a thermal carafe makes more sense. Moccamaster also sells thermal-carafe models; check its site for current options.

Keep it brewing well: whichever you buy, follow the maker's cleaning and descaling instructions. Regular descaling keeps mineral buildup from affecting the machine.

Frequently asked questions

Is the Moccamaster worth it?

+

If you want a simple, SCA-certified brewer with a 5-year warranty, handmade in the Netherlands, yes. If you want a timer or thermal carafe, the Breville may suit you better.

Which drip coffee maker has a timer?

+

Of these three, only the Breville Luxe Brewer, with a delayed start up to 24 hours.

What is the best cheap SCA-certified coffee maker?

+

The Bonavita Connoisseur ($189.99), which holds 195–205°F through the brew.

What does SCA certified mean?

+

The Specialty Coffee Association certifies home brewers that pass third-party testing for brewing quality and consistency.

Sources

Aditya Gudlavalleti
Aditya Gudlavalleti

Watches & Coffee Writer

Aditya is a passionate coffee lover who loves watches. He covers watches and coffee for Man Made Things.

More from Aditya →

Keep reading