Skip to content
Man MadeThings

The 7 Best Everyday Bourbons Worth Keeping on Your Shelf

Seven widely available bourbons worth keeping on your shelf, with official proof, age, designations and tasting notes from the distilleries: Knob Creek 9, Buffalo Trace, Henry McKenna Single Barrel Bottled-in-Bond, Old Forester 1920, Maker's Mark, Elijah Craig Small Batch and Wild Turkey 101.

RVRahul VithalaEditor-in-ChiefPublished · 5 min read

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. Learn more

Bottle of Knob Creek 9 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon
Image: Knob Creek

Quick answer

Seven everyday bourbons worth keeping on hand: Knob Creek 9 Year (100 proof, aged nine years) as the best overall; Buffalo Trace as the classic all-rounder; Henry McKenna Single Barrel (10 years, Bottled-in-Bond); Old Forester 1920 (115 proof) for a bold pour; Maker's Mark (90 proof) for a wheated, softer style; Elijah Craig Small Batch (94 proof); and Wild Turkey 101, which the distillery calls the perfect bourbon for an old fashioned. Distilleries don't publish US prices, so check your local shop.

You don't need a rare, allocated bottle to enjoy great bourbon. Some of the best are on almost every liquor store shelf, and they're the ones worth knowing.

I picked seven widely available bourbons, each for a different taste or use. Every proof, age, designation and tasting note comes from the distillery's own website. One honest note on price: none of these distilleries publishes a US suggested retail price, and prices vary a lot by state and store, so I haven't quoted prices. Check your local shop for current prices.

You must be 21 or older to buy alcohol. Please drink responsibly. To understand the words on these labels, read our De/code: a whiskey label.

Our picks at a glance

  1. Bottle of Knob Creek 9 Year Old bourbon

    Best overall

    Knob Creek 9 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon

    US price not listed by maker

    Check price ↗
  2. Bottle of Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon

    Best classic all-rounder

    Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon

    US price not listed by maker

    Check price ↗
  3. Bottle of Henry McKenna Single Barrel 10 Year Bottled-in-Bond

    Best bottled-in-bond

    Henry McKenna Single Barrel 10 Year Bottled-in-Bond

    US price not listed by maker

    Check price ↗
  4. Bottle of Old Forester 1920 Prohibition Style bourbon

    Best high-proof

    Old Forester 1920 Prohibition Style

    US price not listed by maker

    Check price ↗
  5. Bottle of Maker's Mark bourbon with red wax

    Best wheated (softer) bourbon

    Maker's Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon

    US price not listed by maker

    Check price ↗
  6. Bottle of Elijah Craig Small Batch bourbon

    Best small batch

    Elijah Craig Small Batch

    US price not listed by maker

    Check price ↗
  7. Bottle of Wild Turkey bourbon

    Best for cocktails

    Wild Turkey 101 Kentucky Straight Bourbon

    US price not listed by maker

    Check price ↗

1. Best overall

Knob Creek 9 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon

Bottle of Knob Creek 9 Year Old bourbon
Image: Knob Creek

Knob Creek says it ages this bourbon in white oak barrels for nine years and bottles it at 100 proof, and states that age right on the label. The distillery describes it as "full-bodied with layers of caramel, vanilla, charred oak, and subtle fruit." Great neat, with a splash of water, or in a stirred cocktail.

Pros

  1. 019-year age statement
  2. 02100 proof
  3. 03Rich, full-bodied style

Cons

  1. 01Price not listed by maker
Proof100 (50% ABV)
Age9 years
DesignationKentucky Straight Bourbon
DistilleryKnob Creek, Clermont, KY

2. Best classic all-rounder

Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon

Bottle of Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon
Image: Buffalo Trace Distillery

Buffalo Trace Distillery says it has won over 100 awards and honors in the past two decades. It's a Kentucky straight bourbon that works neat, on ice or in cocktails. The distillery's page doesn't list tasting notes or an age statement.

Pros

  1. 01Widely available
  2. 02Versatile
  3. 03Award-winning, per the distillery

Cons

  1. 01No age statement
  2. 02Distillery publishes few details
DesignationKentucky Straight Bourbon
DistilleryBuffalo Trace, Frankfort, KY
AwardsOver 100 awards in two decades, per the distillery

3. Best bottled-in-bond

Henry McKenna Single Barrel 10 Year Bottled-in-Bond

Bottle of Henry McKenna Single Barrel 10 Year Bottled-in-Bond
Image: Heaven Hill

Heaven Hill calls this "one of the longest aged Bottled-in-Bond whiskeys available today." Bottled-in-Bond means, by US law, one distillery, one distilling season, at least four years old and exactly 100 proof; this one is 10 years and drawn from a single barrel. Heaven Hill describes "smooth oak, sharp spices, honey, and sweetness."

Pros

  1. 0110-year age statement
  2. 02Bottled-in-Bond guarantees
  3. 03Single barrel

Cons

  1. 01Price not listed by maker
  2. 02Varies barrel to barrel
Proof100
Age10 years
DesignationSingle barrel, Bottled-in-Bond
DistilleryHeaven Hill, Bardstown, KY

4. Best high-proof

Old Forester 1920 Prohibition Style

Bottle of Old Forester 1920 Prohibition Style bourbon
Image: Old Forester

At 115 proof, this is the boldest pour here. Old Forester describes "dark caramel" coating "layers of malt nuttiness, chocolate and nougat." Add a few drops of water to open it up, or use it in a cocktail that needs to stand up to ice.

Pros

  1. 01Rich, bold flavor
  2. 02115 proof

Cons

  1. 01Strong for beginners
  2. 02No age statement
Proof115
DesignationStraight bourbon
DistilleryOld Forester, Louisville, KY

5. Best wheated (softer) bourbon

Maker's Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon

Bottle of Maker's Mark bourbon with red wax
Image: Maker's Mark

Maker's Mark uses soft red winter wheat in its mash bill, which the distillery calls "the star of our mash bill." Maker's describes it as "sweet, with a balance of oak, vanilla and fruity essences." A good first bourbon, and recognizable by its red wax.

Pros

  1. 01Soft, approachable style
  2. 02Easy to find
  3. 03Great first bourbon

Cons

  1. 01No age statement
  2. 02Less bold than higher-proof picks
Proof90
Mash billWheated (soft red winter wheat)
DesignationKentucky Straight Bourbon
DistilleryMaker's Mark, Loretto, KY

6. Best small batch

Elijah Craig Small Batch

Bottle of Elijah Craig Small Batch bourbon
Image: Heaven Hill

Heaven Hill says Elijah Craig Small Batch is a blend of bourbons aged 8 to 12 years, bottled at 94 proof, with aromas of "vanilla bean, sweet fruit and fresh mint." Remember, "small batch" has no legal definition, but Heaven Hill's age range tells you more than most labels do.

Pros

  1. 01Mature 8–12-year blend
  2. 0294 proof
  3. 03Versatile

Cons

  1. 01'Small batch' isn't legally defined
Proof94
Age8–12 years old, per Heaven Hill
DesignationSmall batch

7. Best for cocktails

Wild Turkey 101 Kentucky Straight Bourbon

Bottle of Wild Turkey bourbon
Image: Wild Turkey

Wild Turkey calls 101 "the perfect bourbon for an old fashioned cocktail," and its higher proof holds up well with sugar, bitters and ice. The distillery says it's aged 6 to 8 years and describes a finish of "bold, signature Wild Turkey spice and orange peel."

Pros

  1. 01Built for cocktails
  2. 02101 proof
  3. 036–8 years old

Cons

  1. 01Spicy style isn't for everyone
Proof101
Age6–8 years, per Wild Turkey
DesignationKentucky Straight Bourbon
DistilleryWild Turkey, Lawrenceburg, KY

All seven at a glance

Seven everyday bourbons by proof: Maker's Mark 90, Elijah Craig Small Batch 94, Knob Creek 9 100, Henry McKenna 10 100, Wild Turkey 101 101, Old Forester 1920 115
Image: Man Made Things
Bourbon Proof Age Style
Maker's Mark 90 No age statement Wheated, soft
Buffalo Trace See label No age statement Classic all-rounder
Elijah Craig Small Batch 94 8–12 years Small batch
Knob Creek 9 100 9 years Full-bodied
Henry McKenna Single Barrel 100 10 years Bottled-in-Bond
Wild Turkey 101 101 6–8 years Spicy, cocktail-ready
Old Forester 1920 115 No age statement Bold, rich

How to choose a bourbon

How to choose a bourbon: wheated for softer and sweeter, rye-forward for spicier; higher proof for bolder flavor; age statements and bottled-in-bond for guarantees
Image: Man Made Things
  • Softer and sweeter? Try Maker's Mark, a wheated bourbon the distillery describes as sweet.
  • Bolder? Higher proof, like Old Forester 1920 at 115, means more intensity. Add a few drops of water to taste.
  • Want guarantees? Look for an age statement or Bottled-in-Bond, which by law means one distillery, one season, at least four years and 100 proof.
  • For cocktails: a higher-proof bourbon like Wild Turkey 101 stands up to ice and sugar.

Our bourbon vs rye vs Scotch explainer covers the differences between styles.

How to taste bourbon

How to taste bourbon: use a tulip-shaped glass, nose it gently, sip neat first, then add a few drops of water and compare
Image: Man Made Things
  1. Use a good glass. A tulip or nosing glass concentrates aromas. See our best whiskey glasses.
  2. Nose gently. High-proof spirits can overwhelm your nose; breathe in slowly with your mouth slightly open.
  3. Sip it neat first, then add a few drops of water and taste again. Water can open up flavors, especially in higher-proof bourbons.
  4. Compare two side by side, like a wheated Maker's Mark and a spicier Wild Turkey 101, to learn what you like.

Buying for someone else? See our best gifts for whiskey lovers.

Reading a bourbon label

Bourbon label terms: straight means aged at least two years; bottled-in-bond means one distillery, one season, at least four years and 100 proof; small batch and single barrel are not legally defined
Image: Man Made Things

A few words on the label tell you a lot:

  • Bourbon: by US rules, made in the United States from at least 51% corn and aged in new charred oak containers.
  • Straight bourbon: aged at least two years. If it's younger than four years, the label must state the age.
  • Kentucky straight bourbon: straight bourbon made in Kentucky, like most picks here.
  • Bottled-in-Bond: one distillery, one distilling season, at least four years old and bottled at 100 proof, as with the Henry McKenna.
  • Small batch and single barrel: common terms with no legal definition. Single barrel usually means each bottle comes from one cask, so flavor can vary bottle to bottle.

Our De/code: a whiskey label covers every term in detail.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good everyday bourbon?

+

Knob Creek 9 Year, Buffalo Trace, Maker's Mark and Wild Turkey 101 are all widely available and well regarded.

What is a wheated bourbon?

+

A bourbon that uses wheat as a key grain in its mash bill, like Maker's Mark, which the distillery describes as sweet with oak and vanilla.

What does Bottled-in-Bond mean?

+

By US law: one distillery, one distilling season, at least four years old and bottled at exactly 100 proof.

Why don't you list prices?

+

None of these distilleries publishes a US suggested retail price, and prices vary by state and store.

Sources

RV
Rahul Vithala

Editor-in-Chief

Rahul has been writing about gadgets and software since 2013, first at Thetechhacker and now at Man Made Things. He edits every review on the site and signs off on every verdict.

More from Rahul →

Keep reading