The Best Cast Iron Skillets: Lodge, Smithey and Staub
Three cast iron skillets for three kinds of cooks: the $37 Lodge Classic, the polished Smithey No. 12 and the enameled Staub fry pan, plus how caring for each differs.
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. Learn more

Quick answer
The Lodge Classic 12" skillet ($36.95 list) is the best cast iron skillet for most people: made in the USA, pre-seasoned and induction-friendly. The Smithey No. 12 ($220) is the premium pick, with a polished, satin-smooth cooking surface. The Staub 10-inch enameled fry pan ($229.99) needs no seasoning and can go in the dishwasher.
Every kitchen should have one cast iron skillet. It sears a steak better than almost anything else, goes from stovetop to oven to campfire, and if you look after it, it will outlive you.
But "cast iron skillet" covers a surprising range. There's the classic $30 pan that's been on American stoves for generations. There are premium skillets with a smooth, polished cooking surface that cost seven times as much. And there's enameled cast iron, which skips the seasoning entirely.
I picked one of each and checked every spec and price on the brand's own US site. These are research-based picks with no star scores. Once you've got your pan, our guide to seasoning cast iron will keep it in shape. Let's get into it.
Our picks at a glance
1. Best overall
Lodge Classic Cast Iron Skillet, 12-inch

This is the pan I'd tell almost anyone to buy first. Lodge has made cast iron in the US for a very long time, and the Classic skillet is about as proven as cookware gets. It arrives pre-seasoned with vegetable oil, so you can cook on it straight away.
It works on any stovetop, including induction, plus the oven, the grill and even a campfire. Lodge also points out it's made without PFAS, which matters if you're moving away from nonstick coatings.
The 12-inch size is the most versatile for a family, but it's heavy at 7.69 pounds. If that's too much, the 10.25-inch version is lighter and cheaper. The cooking surface is as-cast, meaning slightly pebbly rather than smooth, but it gets slicker as you cook with it. Lodge had it on sale for $29.90 when I checked.
Pros
- 01Incredible value
- 02Made in the USA
- 03Pre-seasoned and ready to use
- 04Works on induction, oven, grill and campfire
Cons
- 01Heavy at 7.69 lb for the 12-inch
- 02Rougher as-cast surface than premium pans
- 03Must be hand-washed
| Size | 12 in (also 3.5 to 15 in) |
|---|---|
| Weight | 7.69 lb |
| Length | 18 in with handle |
| Pre-seasoned | 100% natural vegetable oil |
| Finish | As-cast, straight from the foundry |
| Heat sources | Any stovetop including induction, oven, grill, campfire |
| Made in | USA |
2. Best premium
Smithey No. 12 Cast Iron Skillet

The Smithey is what cast iron looks like when it's treated as an heirloom. The interior is polished to a satin-smooth finish, which makes it slicker out of the box and easier to clean than an as-cast pan. Smithey hand-applies two to three coats of grapeseed oil to pre-season it, with no chemical coatings.
The details are lovely too. There are pour spouts on both sides, a three-hole helper handle so you can lift it with two hands, and holes for hanging. It's made in the US and works on gas, induction, electric and open fire.
Is it worth $220, about six times the price of the Lodge? For daily cooking, the Lodge does the same job. The Smithey is for people who want a smoother surface from day one and a pan that looks good on the stove. It's also heavy, at about 8 pounds.
Pros
- 01Polished, smooth cooking surface
- 02Pour spouts and helper handle
- 03Made in the USA
- 04Beautiful heirloom design
Cons
- 01Expensive at $220
- 02Heavy at about 8 lb
- 03Oven-safe temperature not listed
| Diameter | 12 in top, 10.5 in cooking surface |
|---|---|
| Depth | 2 in |
| Weight | About 8 lb |
| Finish | Polished, satin-smooth interior |
| Pre-seasoned | 2–3 coats of grapeseed oil, by hand |
| Details | Pour spouts, 3-hole helper handle |
| Made in | USA; works on gas, induction, electric and fire |
3. Best enameled
STAUB Cast Iron 10-inch Fry Pan

If the idea of seasoning and oiling a pan sounds like a chore, enameled cast iron is your answer. Staub coats the iron in a black matte enamel that needs no seasoning, won't rust and can be washed with soap and water. Staub even lists it as dishwasher safe, though it recommends hand washing to keep the enamel looking its best.
The textured enamel interior is designed for searing, and the pan is oven safe to 500°F and works on every stovetop, including induction. It's lighter than the other two at 4.89 pounds for the 10-inch, and it's made in France with a lifetime warranty.
The trade-off is care of a different kind. Enamel can chip if you bang metal utensils on the rim, and Staub warns against heating the pan empty over high heat or moving it straight from the fridge to a hot burner.
Pros
- 01No seasoning needed, won't rust
- 02Dishwasher safe per Staub
- 03Lighter at 4.89 lb
- 04Made in France with a lifetime warranty
Cons
- 01Enamel can chip
- 02Avoid high heat when empty and sudden temperature changes
- 03Expensive at $229.99
| Diameter | 10.24 in top, 8.35 in bottom |
|---|---|
| Weight | 4.89 lb |
| Interior | Black matte enamel, textured for searing |
| Seasoning | None required |
| Oven safe | Up to 500°F |
| Heat sources | All stovetops including induction |
| Made in | France; lifetime warranty |
Bare vs enameled cast iron: how care differs
Bare cast iron (Lodge, Smithey) builds up seasoning as you cook. Lodge says it should be washed by hand, because a dishwasher will strip the seasoning and likely cause rust. Don't soak it either. Lodge calls soaking "a recipe for rust." Use a nylon brush or pan scraper for stuck-on food, dry it right away and wipe on a thin layer of oil.
Enameled cast iron (Staub) needs none of that. Staub says it requires no seasoning, won't rust and is easy to clean. The rules are about protecting the enamel: don't strike metal utensils on the rim, don't use knives or blenders inside it, and avoid sudden temperature changes.
Bare iron gets better with age and can be restored if it rusts. Enamel stays the same but can't be re-seasoned if it chips.
Which size should you buy?
Size matters more than people expect, mostly because of weight.
- 10 to 10.25 inches: the best all-rounder for one or two people. Big enough for two steaks or a few eggs, and much easier to lift.
- 12 inches: the family size. Fits a whole chicken thigh dinner or a big batch of vegetables, but it's heavy. The Lodge 12" weighs 7.69 pounds before you add food.
- Smaller sizes: great for single servings, cornbread or as a second pan.
If you can only buy one, I'd start with a 10-inch and add a 12-inch later if you find yourself running out of room. And whatever size you pick, use a dry towel or oven mitt on the handle. Cast iron handles get just as hot as the pan, which catches out a lot of first-time owners. A silicone handle cover is a cheap fix.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best cast iron skillet?
+
The Lodge Classic 12-inch skillet, at $36.95 list. It's made in the USA, pre-seasoned with vegetable oil and works on induction, in the oven and over a campfire.
Is an expensive cast iron skillet worth it?
+
For cooking performance, a Lodge does the job. Premium pans like the Smithey No. 12 add a polished, smooth surface, pour spouts and a helper handle.
Can you put cast iron in the dishwasher?
+
Not bare cast iron. Lodge says a dishwasher removes the seasoning and likely causes rust. Staub lists its enameled cast iron as dishwasher safe but recommends hand washing.
Does enameled cast iron need seasoning?
+
No. Staub says its enameled cast iron requires no seasoning and won't rust.
Sources
Editor-in-Chief
Rahul has been writing about gadgets and software since 2013, first at Thetechhacker and now at Man Made Things. He edits every review on the site and signs off on every verdict.
More from Rahul →
