Skip to content
Man MadeThings

The Best Dutch Ovens: Staub and Lodge

Three Dutch ovens for soups, stews, braises and bread: the French-made Staub La Cocotte, Lodge's enameled 6-quart and Lodge's classic bare cast iron 5-quart.

RVRahul VithalaEditor-in-ChiefPublished · 5 min read

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. Learn more

Staub La Cocotte round Dutch oven in matte black
Image: Staub

Quick answer

The Staub La Cocotte 7 qt ($469.99 list, often on sale) is the best premium Dutch oven, made in France with a self-basting lid. The Lodge 6 qt Essential Enamel Dutch Oven ($99.95 list) is the best value and oven safe to 500°F. For camping and bread, the bare cast iron Lodge 5 qt ($69.95 list) is made in the USA and works over a campfire.

If a cast iron skillet is the workhorse of the kitchen, the Dutch oven is the slow-cooker, stockpot and bread oven rolled into one. It's the pot you reach for on a cold Sunday: beef stew, chili, braised short ribs, a whole chicken, or a crusty loaf of bread.

The basic idea hasn't changed in centuries. A heavy cast iron pot holds heat evenly, and a tight lid keeps moisture in. What has changed is the choice. You can spend $60 or nearly $500, and the difference comes down to enamel, where it's made and the little details.

I picked three for three budgets and checked every spec and price on the brand's own US site. These are research-based picks with no star scores. Let's get into it.

Our picks at a glance

  1. Staub La Cocotte 7 qt round Dutch oven

    Best premium

    Staub La Cocotte Round Dutch Oven, 7 qt

    List price $469.99

    Check price ↗
  2. Lodge 6 quart enameled Dutch oven
    Check price ↗
  3. Lodge 5 quart cast iron Dutch oven with lid

    Best bare cast iron

    Lodge Cast Iron Dutch Oven, 5 qt

    List price $69.95

    Check price ↗

1. Best premium

Staub La Cocotte Round Dutch Oven, 7 qt

Staub La Cocotte 7 qt round Dutch oven
Image: Staub

Staub's La Cocotte has been made in France since 1974, and it's a pot people hand down. The lid is the clever part: its underside is covered in little spikes that collect moisture as it rises and drip it back onto the food. That's why Staub calls it self-basting, and it's great for braises that need to stay juicy for hours.

Inside, the black matte enamel is designed for browning and caramelizing, so you can sear meat directly in the pot before adding liquid. It needs no seasoning, works on every stovetop including induction, and is oven safe to 500°F. Staub backs it with a lifetime warranty.

The 7-quart size feeds a family or a dinner party, but it's heavy. The list price is $469.99, though Staub had it on sale for $299.99 when I checked. Staub also makes a 5.5-quart version if you cook for fewer people.

Pros

  1. 01Self-basting spiked lid keeps food moist
  2. 02Black matte enamel browns well
  3. 03Made in France, lifetime warranty
  4. 04Frequently discounted from list price

Cons

  1. 01Expensive at list price
  2. 02Heavy
  3. 03Avoid metal utensils on the enamel
Capacity7 qt (about 28 cups)
Diameter28 cm (about 11 in)
InteriorBlack matte enamel
LidHeavy, self-basting with interior spikes
Oven safeUp to 500°F
StovetopAll, including induction
Made inFrance; limited lifetime warranty

2. Best value

Lodge 6 Quart Essential Enamel Dutch Oven

Lodge 6 quart enameled Dutch oven
Image: Lodge Cast Iron

This is the Dutch oven I'd recommend to most people. You get enameled cast iron that cooks much like the expensive French pots for around a quarter of the price.

It holds 6 quarts, works on any stovetop including induction, and is oven safe to 500°F. Lodge includes pot protectors to stop the lid chipping the rim in storage, and its stainless steel knob and loop handles are easy to grab with oven mitts. Lodge's warranty covers enamel chips and cracks from normal cooking, which is reassuring at this price.

A few honest notes. Lodge makes its enameled pieces with partners in China or Vietnam, unlike its US-made bare cast iron. It recommends hand washing and no metal utensils. And Lodge says there's no need to cook above medium heat on the stove, because prolonged high heat can damage the enamel.

Pros

  1. 01About a quarter of the price of premium brands
  2. 02Oven safe to 500°F
  3. 03Works on induction
  4. 04Warranty covers enamel chips in normal use

Cons

  1. 01Made in China or Vietnam
  2. 02Hand wash and no metal utensils
  3. 03Heavy at 13.5 lb
Capacity6 qt
Size13.25 × 11.6 × 6 in, 13.52 lb
Oven safeUp to 500°F
StovetopAny, including induction
CareHand wash recommended; no metal utensils
Made inChina or Vietnam
WarrantyLimited lifetime (covers enamel chips in normal use)

3. Best bare cast iron

Lodge Cast Iron Dutch Oven, 5 qt

Lodge 5 quart cast iron Dutch oven with lid
Image: Lodge Cast Iron

The bare cast iron Dutch oven is the original, and it's the most versatile. Lodge's 5-quart works on any stovetop, in the oven, on the grill and right in a campfire, which no enameled pot should go near.

It arrives pre-seasoned with vegetable oil and is made in the USA. Bare cast iron can handle very high heat, which makes it a favorite for baking crusty bread, and over years of use the seasoning builds into a naturally slick surface. If it ever rusts, you can scrub and re-season it.

The trade-off is care and acidity. Like a skillet, it needs hand washing, drying and a little oil, and long-simmered acidic dishes like tomato sauce can wear the seasoning down. For those, the enameled Lodge is a better choice. Lodge had it on sale for $59.90 when I checked.

Pros

  1. 01Goes from stove to oven to campfire
  2. 02Made in the USA
  3. 03Very affordable
  4. 04Can be restored if it rusts

Cons

  1. 01Needs seasoning care like a skillet
  2. 02Not ideal for long acidic simmers
  3. 03Heavy at 13.3 lb
Capacity5 qt (also 2 and 7 qt)
Size12.56 × 10.43 × 7.14 in, 13.29 lb
FinishBare cast iron, seasoned with vegetable oil
Heat sourcesAny stovetop including induction, oven, grill, campfire
CareHand wash, dry, oil
Made inUSA

Enameled vs bare cast iron Dutch ovens

Comparison of enameled and bare cast iron Dutch ovens
Image: Man Made Things

Enameled Dutch ovens, like the Staub and the enameled Lodge, have a glass-like coating fused to the iron. They need no seasoning, won't rust, and handle acidic foods like tomato sauce and wine braises without any problem. The trade-off is that the enamel can chip and doesn't like very high heat or sudden temperature changes.

Bare cast iron, like the classic Lodge, is tougher and cheaper. It handles high heat, campfires and the grill, and it lasts basically forever. But it needs seasoning, hand washing and oiling, and long acidic simmers can strip its seasoning.

If you only want one, go enameled for everyday soups and stews. Add a bare one later if you camp or bake a lot of bread.

How to use and care for a Dutch oven

Dutch oven tips: preheat low, cook at medium, avoid sudden temperature changes, hand wash
Image: Man Made Things

Cast iron holds heat so well that you rarely need high heat.

  • Preheat gently. Staub says to preheat over low heat for a few minutes, then move up to medium-low or medium. It warns never to heat its pots rapidly over high heat or leave them empty on a burner for a long time.
  • Stay at medium or below. Lodge says there's no need to cook above medium on the stove with enameled cast iron, because prolonged high heat can damage the enamel. Even with bare cast iron, Lodge suggests starting at medium-low and working up.
  • Avoid sudden temperature changes. Don't go straight from the fridge to a hot burner or oven.
  • Use wood or silicone utensils on enamel to avoid chips.
  • Clean according to type. Enameled pots can be washed with soap and water. Bare cast iron gets the same care as a skillet: hand wash, dry immediately and oil lightly. Store it with the lid slightly open or a paper towel inside so moisture can escape.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best Dutch oven?

+

The Staub La Cocotte is our premium pick for its self-basting lid and French build. The Lodge 6 qt Essential Enamel Dutch Oven is the best value.

What size Dutch oven should I buy?

+

A 5 to 6 quart pot suits most households. Go up to 7 quarts if you cook for a family or batch-cook.

Is enameled or bare cast iron better for a Dutch oven?

+

Enameled needs no seasoning and handles acidic foods. Bare cast iron handles higher heat and campfires and is cheaper.

Can a Dutch oven go in the oven?

+

Yes. Staub and Lodge's enameled Dutch ovens are oven safe to 500°F, and bare cast iron Lodge ovens also work on a grill or campfire.

Sources

RV
Rahul Vithala

Editor-in-Chief

Rahul has been writing about gadgets and software since 2013, first at Thetechhacker and now at Man Made Things. He edits every review on the site and signs off on every verdict.

More from Rahul →

Keep reading